Modular Approach to a Sleep System
We originally published this blog back in 2015, partly as a response to the amazing response we had received to the blog posting ‘Modular Packing in your Backpack’ – how to keep order and keep your gear dry in your pack.
In 2015, it seemed as if very few people had given much thought to combining the correct sleeping mat, sleeping bag and liner to form a system; so we gave a couple of examples of how and where this would work.
Fast forward to the present, and the term ‘sleep system’ is certainly more commonly used. Here’s how we at Sea to Summit define it:
In order to get a good night’s sleep, think of the gear you will need in the same way you think of a layered clothing system.
The first component is your ground insulation and comfort layer: the sleeping pad. This has to provide adequate insulation in the conditions you will be camping in, or the warmth from your sleeping bag will be lost into the ground. The second component is the insulation around your body: the sleeping bag. The shape, construction and placement of insulation within the bag are going to be key, or your warmth will be lost into the air. The third component is the next-to-skin layer: the liner. This has the same function as a clothing base layer, wicking moisture and retaining warmth.
Let’s start with the sleeping pad (or as we call them, sleeping mat – our mats are much closer to the comfort level of a mattress than to a conventional pad)
A sleeping pad has two functions: to provide comfort and to insulate you from the cold ground. Not every pad is as comfortable as some marketing departments would want you to believe, so it’s essential to test one before you buy it by laying on the pad, and rolling over to assume different sleeping positions. If it wobbles underneath you, move on to a different design. Not all mats will insulate you from the ground equally well, either. Fortunately, a new industry standard will come into force in January 2020: all sleeping pad manufacturers will now test for the insulation value (R-Value) of their pads using the same test protocol. You will therefore be able to compare R-Values across brands. You can read about comfort and insulation here link to and about R-Value here.
The second component is the sleeping bag.
The sleeping bag is intended to retain your warmth when the outside air temperature is cool or cold. At the risk of repetition, not all sleeping bags retain heat as well as some people claim; not even the ones which are tested using the European EN rating system. Another factor to be aware of is the level of ventilation available in any given design. Some bags have plenty of ventilation options and can be used across a wide temperature spectrum, other bags have a much narrower comfort window. You can read about choosing the right sleeping bag for both cooler and warmer temperatures here.
The third component is a liner.
Most outdoor end-users have heard about sleeping bag liners. They may know that a liner can keep your sleeping bag clean, is easy to wash, and may add a few degrees of warmth. However, it’s much less common to think of a liner as managing moisture in warm or humid conditions. Sea to Summit has liners which can add warmth and which can help keep you from feeling clammy when the temperature and humidity rise. You can read which liner would complete your sleep system here.
A modular sleep system for colder weather environments would work like this: the end-user can choose a slightly lighter and less bulky sleeping bag than otherwise would be the case, and pair it with a Reactor, Reactor Compact Plus, Reactor Extreme, or Thermolite® Fleece Liner to provide adequate warmth.
The sleeping mat would need to deliver the correct level of insulation, i.e. an R-Value of 3 or above. And the sleeping bag will be constructed with warmth-retaining features like a technical hood, a draft collar and a zipper draft tube large enough to really stop drafts. Because all the components in the system are optimized for the conditions in which they are being used, they offer the best possible performance for the least possible weight and packed volume. Compare this with the end-user who didn’t plan in a modular way who carries around a heavier, bulkier sleeping bag without a thermal liner and without an adequately warm sleeping mat – and who is surprised when he or she gets cold.
By the way – the advice in this article is intended for all genders. However, women have specific needs when it comes to sleep systems which you can read about here.
The ideal liner for this is the Coolmax Adaptor (available in Mummy and Traveller shapes), and the perfect sleeping bag is either the Trek or the Journey (both available in different temperature ratings). The sleeping pad might be the Ether Light XT or Ultralight Air.
OK – on to those examples we mentioned above.
Imagine you’re traveling through Southeast Asia: at the beginning of your trip (perhaps in Bangkok), you may be at a lower elevation in warm and humid conditions, maybe even in a budget-priced hotel or hostel. For these conditions, you would sleep in just the Adaptor liner, which would help you sleep more comfortably while keeping you away from less-than-pristine bed sheets. (If there is concern about mosquitoes or bugs, you could also opt for the Coolmax Adaptor liner with Insect Shield). As you travel to higher elevations (say, Chiang Mai), you would sleep in the Adaptor with the Trek or Journey (opened fully as a quilt) over you. As elevation increases further, you would progressively close the zippers (foot zipper and side zipper) on the Trek/Journey until at the coldest point of your trip you would be inside the Adaptor in a fully cinched up sleeping bag.
In the above case, you would be traveling from hostel to hostel, and thus might not have a sleeping mat with you. A pillow, on the other hand, should definitely be part of this system.
THE APPALACHAIN TRAIL
Perhaps the most classic example of the use of a sleep system in moderately cold to warm conditions would be the Appalachian Trail. At the start of the trail in Georgia in April, an Altitude At I or Ascent Ac I would keep you snug and warm with the Adaptor inside it; you might even open the foot box zipper for a little ventilation. Further north in the chillier conditions of the Nantahala Forest, or perhaps the Mount Rogers Wilderness, you may well have all the zippers closed tightly. As you progress through Virginia, and the temperature and humidity increases you would progressively open the side zippers and eventually sleep under the Altitude/Ascent opened like a quilt. In the hot humid nights in Pennsylvania, the Adaptor by itself would suffice, before you head up to New England and once again use the system’s ability to cope with increasingly cold nights.
The soft, stretchy Adaptor liner will provide you with supreme comfort in both the above scenarios. The sleeping mat you would include in this system would have to provide an adequate level of insulation in those colder sections in Virginia and at the northern end of the trail. For this reason, a male end-user might choose the Insulated Ultralight Sleeping Mat (R-Value 3.1) or Ether Light XT Insulated (R-Value 3.2) while a female hiker would choose the Women’s Ultralight Sleeping Mat (R-Value 3.5) or the Women’s Ether Light XT Insulated (R-Value 3.5)
For travel and general backpacking, the Trek and Journey are roomy, comfortable sleeping bags which are surprisingly light – the Tk I weighs only 1lb 13oz/830g, the Journey Jo I weighs 2lbs 2oz/960g. They also have a lot more flexibility than many other sleeping bags because of their built-in ventilation – especially when used with the wicking Adaptor liner or Thermolite® Reactor liner.
And, on the Appalachian Trail, the Ascent/Adaptor together weigh 2lbs 6oz/1080g and the Altitude/Adaptor 2lbs 14oz/1300g.
However, given that weight and packed volume are often paramount on the AT, you may opt for the ultralight Spark Sp III or Flame Fm III which reduces your ventilation options, but also reduces weight and packed volume. Spark Sp III/Adaptor weigh 1lb 14ozs/850g, Flame Fm III weigh 2lbs 0oz/900g together. A pillow is also a key element in a good night's sleep - and the Aeros Pillows are not only incredibly comfortable, they are light and very packable.
Sea to Summit sleeping mats are an integral part of any sleep system – they are more comfortable, easier to inflate and deflate and are made of higher quality materials than any other air-filled sleeping pad. Reading the above-mentioned blog post on the physics of comfort and insulation may take the mystery out of the purchase of a mat (helpful given the prevalence of marketing-speak rather than facts when it comes to sleeping pads).
A Pillow is also a key element in a good night’s sleep – and the Aeros Pillows are not only incredibly comfortable, they are light and very packable.
Finally, remember that the best sleeping bag and liner will only offer very modest comfort if they are wet or even damp. Make sure you pack them away in an appropriate dry-storage option inside your pack (you don’t want to run the risk of snagging your sleep system or even your shelter on a sharp branch or rock). The eVent Compression Dry Sack, eVent UltraSil Compression Dry Sack and eVac Dry Sack are all great candidates for packing away your sleep system.
If you have questions on which liner will work best with your sleeping bag, or which sleeping bag or sleeping mat is most suitable for a particular application, all you have to do is –